Hospitals have been visited, promises and commitments made, hands have been shaken, and photographs taken.
Now that the big health announcements are likely behind us, it’s time to take stock of the health system the next government will inherit, whoever it may be. The post-COVID years have not been kind to hospital emergency departments (EDs) in particular, with soaring patient numbers and surging rates of bed block and staff fatigue. We’ve also seen record levels of violence against ED doctors and nurses, as well as issues supporting the already-stretched medical teams providing local emergency care to regional and rural Victoria.
What does this mean for day one of the next Victorian government? Quite frankly, our EDs are in a dire state, and the numbers emergency physicians watch most closely are all going in the wrong direction.
It’s confronting. Last year the number of patients spending more than 24 hours in a Victorian ED soared by 37 per cent, from 10,320 people to almost 14,200 people. In the past five years the number of older people who spent longer than eight hours in the ED waiting for an inpatient hospital bed rose by nearly 20 per cent.
I see the people behind these numbers every time I walk into an ED. The older patient who has spent all night on a trolley in a corridor. The nurse who has been hit or spat at for trying to help. The empty roster spots, especially in our regional and rural EDs.
According to figures from a recent Australasian College for Emergency Medicine (ACEM) survey, 88 per cent of Victorian EDs reported verbal violence occurring in their ED once or more per week, while 44 per cent reported physical violence. Meanwhile, ACEM figures also reveal 35 per cent of respondents based in Victoria plan to leave emergency medicine in the next 10 years, an increase from 30 per cent in 2019.
To their credit, the major parties contesting the election have acknowledged these ED security issues with commitments of varying size and detail.
Labor’s $1.5 billion ED election campaign launch saw it promise to cut ED waits by up to 20 per cent by expanding 12 EDs across the state and adding 1500 health workers, 750 of them nurses. It said a separate $277m hospitals package will fund the expansion or upgrade of other EDs across the state.
The Liberal-National Coalition says it will cut ED waits and improve ambulance flow with its new $99 million Patient Transit Lounge Fund for 10 new or expanded discharge lounges, prioritising the sites with the worst overcrowding and ramping. It says it will also fund an expansion of the ED at Bairnsdale Hospital.
For their part, the Greens have supported measures to address staffing shortages, overcrowding, long waits for beds and inadequate access to mental healthcare. They also supported significantly increasing investment in preventative health care and community health services to bring down demand for emergency care, and more investment in rehabilitation, aged care and allied health so people can get out of hospital sooner to free up beds for those who need them.
One Nation says it will address Victoria’s health issues by growing the regional health workforce, expanding regional specialist trainee posts and adding capacity to free up acute beds, reduce bed block, and cut unnecessary hospital stays. It has also committed to publishing hospital triage performance and setting public targets that reduce ramping through beds, discharge speed, nurse practitioners and ward capacity.
It’s worth mentioning at this point that no party has released a whole-of-hospital plan to address bed block.
On ED violence, the Liberal-National Coalition started early with a commitment to improve hospital security by placing extra protective services officers (PSOs) in seven hospitals across Victoria.
The Greens backed calls from ACEM and the College of Emergency Nursing Australasia (CENA) for specialist security, more staff and urgent action on overcrowding, warning that heavy-handed responses to escalating hospital violence disregard what frontline staff are calling for and miss the mark on what will actually work to reduce violence. They also supported the call for the re-establishment of the Victorian Violence in Healthcare Taskforce, which ACEM welcomes as a step towards real change in ED security.
When it comes down to it, any recognition of violence in emergency departments and a commitment to addressing it is just what emergency physicians need. ACEM looks forward to working closely with the next government to ensure any new safety measures are built for the ED environment, include training specific to health care settings.
Everyone wants the same outcome: fewer and less serious violent incidents. In a health setting, we need to be ready to recognise when there’s a medical reason behind someone’s distress, and skilled to respond appropriately.
So, where to from here? The ED situation is challenging, but there is hope. Emergency physicians are pragmatic and problem-solving by nature, trained to find solutions to save lives while working under extreme pressure. Based on this every day, real-life, lived experience, ACEM has offered proposals to tackle some of the most urgent issues we see affecting Victorian ED every day. It’s a big job, but there are achievable things we can do right now to make things better and safer.
Firstly, we need to reduce ED overcrowding and bed block. Let there be no confusion here - no patient should ever spend more than 24 hours in an ED. This is a serious and avoidable safety breach and, as such, requires nothing less than a Ministerial Directive drawing a firm line in the sand that 24-hour waits should never happen.
Victoria also needs at least 2000 additional staffed inpatient beds by 2030–31, and to establish a $60 million Victorian Hospital Flow Innovation Fund to tackle ED overcrowding and bed block by supporting local solutions.
We also need to prioritise reducing the level of violence in the ED. It’s a sad sign of the times that many nurses, doctors, and other ED staff do not feel they have consistent access to the trained security support they need when incidents escalate out of control.
As an emergency physician, I can say first-hand that highly trained security working hand-in-hand with the ED clinical team is a gamechanger. As doctors, we often know when a situation is starting to turn, and having security officers who know our patients, know our team and are trained to de-escalate means we can step in early, before anyone gets hurt. Good ED security isn’t about force. It’s about prevention, trust and teamwork, and that’s what keeps both staff and patients safe.
To be frank, every Victorian ED needs dedicated full-time security officers, trained specifically for healthcare settings, trauma-informed, and employed as part of the team and available 24/7.
We need to make it easier for people to train as dedicated ED security officers and offer them clear protections and guidance so they can do their job effectively and safely.
But there’s even more we can do in this regard. We need to strengthen statewide leadership and accountability by re-establishing the Victorian Violence in Healthcare Taskforce, with a direct reporting line to the Minister for Health. This taskforce would bring together frontline clinicians, health services, government and key agencies to drive a more coordinated statewide response to violence against all healthcare workers and help ensure this remains a clear government priority.
Finally, we need to strengthen emergency care in regional and rural Victoria. In many parts of Victoria, EDs and urgent care services rely heavily on GPs and rural generalists to provide frontline emergency care. Without question – doctors in regional and rural areas do an amazing job and provide exceptional levels of emergency care. However, giving them the opportunity to expand their emergency medicine skills even more helps improve patient care, workforce capability and system resilience by reducing unnecessary transfers, supporting faster patient assessment, and keeping patients closer to home.
Let’s remember that high-quality emergency care is not optional in our health system This makes these proposals worth every cent in terms of how much they could increase the number of trained emergency doctors across regional and rural areas of Victoria.
As November 28 draws ever closer, emergency doctors stand ready to work with the next government to tackle the issues plaguing hospital EDs. Our patients simply can’t afford to wait any longer.
Statement attributable to emergency physician and ACEM Victoria Branch Chair Associate Professor Mark Putland
Background:
ACEM is the peak body for emergency medicine in Australia and Aotearoa New Zealand, responsible for training emergency physicians and advancement of professional standards. www.acem.org.au
Media Contact:
[email protected]
Helen Johnson, Manager, Media and Publications [email protected] +61 427 621 857
Nick Buchan, Media Advisor [email protected] +61 481 918 488
Daphne Atkinson, Media Advisor [email protected] +64 21 057 2706